Classic Coney Sauce Recipe – Thick And Rich Flavor

Experience a taste of nostalgia with our Classic Coney Sauce Recipe! This timeless recipe is simmered to perfection in just 30 minutes and crafted from high-quality ground beef, diced onions, savory tomato sauce, and a secret blend of spices. The result? A rich, hearty sauce perfect for topping hot dogs, burgers, and fries.

Contents show

The intoxicating aroma of a unique sauce drew me into a bustling marketplace in Barcelona, Spain. What I saw was a deep, rich hue with a texture promising a burst of flavors.

When I tasted it, it transported me back to memories of my grandmother’s kitchen, the sensation of warmth and nostalgia wrapping around me. 

Classic Coney Sauce

It was classic coney sauce. Its bold flavor, aromatic allure, and captivating appearance made my journey unforgettable. Remember, the key to any memorable dish is its accompanying sauce. 

So, in this article, let’s get deep into the recipe behind creating a spectacular sauce at home. If you’re deciding to elevate your culinary experiences, this may help. 

Other than this, we will soon introduce articles on The Best Thai Peanut Sauce, Spicy Clam Sauce, Pork Chile Rojo, and Zesty Tomato Sauce.

They are other great sauces to ensure your meals leave a lasting impression. So, without any due, let’s get started with the recipe. 

What Is Classic Coney Sauce?

Classic Coney Sauce is a savory meat sauce typically used as a topping for hot dogs. This sauce originates from the Coney Island region and is distinct from regular chili. It boasts a fine-ground beef base seasoned with a blend of spices. 

The aroma is mouth-watering, and its appearance is thick and rich. Coney Sauce can be the key to achieving that if you decide to add depth to your hot dog or burgers

My advice: ensure your next barbeque has this sauce to elevate the taste. It’s a great way to eliminate the mundane from your grilling experience.

History Of Classic Coney Sauce 

Classic Coney Sauce traces its roots to Coney Island, New York. However, its popularization as a hot dog topping began in the Midwest, notably in Detroit, Michigan.

The immigrants, typically from Greece and Macedonia, brought their culinary traditions and adapted them to American tastes. 

They may have been the key to transforming a simple hot dog into a flavorful treat. The sauce typically contains finely ground beef and a distinct blend of spices.

Though the exact inventor remains debated, the impact of these immigrants on this dish is undeniable. 

Interesting Facts About Classic Coney Sauce  

  • Classic Coney Sauce isn’t technically a “chili” despite its similarities.
  • Its origins are tied to Coney Island, New York, but it’s fame skyrocketed in Detroit, Michigan.
  • Typically, Greek and Macedonian immigrants played a significant role in popularizing this sauce.
  • The sauce can vary in spiciness and consistency based on regional preferences.
  • Many restaurants claim to have the “original” recipe, but variations abound.
  • Some recipes might add unique ingredients like chocolate or coffee for depth.
  • If you’re deciding on a hot dog topping, Coney Sauce is among the top choices in the Midwest.
  • It’s a great way to find a way to elevate even the simplest dishes.
  • Coney Sauce can be found canned, but aficionados often insist on homemade versions.
  • Contrary to belief, the sauce contains no beans, distinguishing it from regular chili.
Classic Coney Sauce

What Are The Regional Adaptations Of This Sauce? 

Classic Coney Sauce has various regional adaptations, reflecting the diverse tastes across America. In Detroit, it’s typically a smooth, finely ground beef sauce with a hint of spiciness. 

Flint, Michigan, offers a drier, chunkier version. Over in Jackson, Michigan, the sauce is often ground coarser and has a noticeable onion presence. Toledo’s take is spicier and sometimes includes hints of cumin or paprika

If you’re deciding to travel the Midwest, each stop may offer a different twist on this beloved sauce. 

What Will Make You Love This Classic Coney Sauce? 

The allure of Classic Coney Sauce lies in its rich, savory flavor. Its finely ground beef base, seasoned with a unique blend of spices, can turn a simple dish into an exquisite meal. 

The sauce’s texture, ranging from smooth to slightly chunky, caters to varied preferences. Remember that consistency is vital when deciding what makes a topping stand out. The aroma, a delightful blend of meaty and spicy notes, promises a taste adventure. 

I advise you to try this sauce; its depth of flavor may win your heart. Additionally, the sauce’s ability to elevate even mundane dishes is unparalleled. This is a great way to ensure your meals leave a lasting, flavorful impression.

Classic Coney Sauce

Ingredients List

IngredientQuantity
Ground beef2 pounds
Chopped onion1/2 cup
Ketchup1 1/2 cups
White sugar1/4 cup
White vinegar1/4 cup
Prepared yellow mustard1/4 cup
Celery seed1/2 teaspoon
Worcestershire sauce3/4 teaspoon
Ground black pepper1/2 teaspoon
Salt3/4 teaspoon

Ingredient Tips 

  • Choose high-quality ground beef with a good fat content for a richer flavor.
  • Freshly chop onions rather than using pre-packaged ones for better aroma and crunch.
  • Opt for organic ketchup; it typically has a more genuine tomato flavor and fewer additives.
  • Use cane sugar instead of refined white sugar for a subtle molasses hint.
  • Freshly squeezed white vinegar can make a noticeable difference in taste.
  • Stone-ground mustard can be a great substitute for yellow mustard, adding depth.
  • Toasting celery seeds slightly before adding them can enhance their flavor.
  • Authentic Worcestershire sauce is vital to the sauce’s distinct taste.
  • Grinding black pepper freshly ensures a bolder flavor.
  • Always taste-test before adding salt, as saltiness can vary between brands.

What Are The Variations Of Classic Coney Sauce Recipe? 

  • Vegetarian Version: Replace ground beef with lentils or finely chopped mushrooms.
  • Spicy Twist: Add red pepper flakes or cayenne for an extra kick.
  • Sweet Variation: Incorporate brown sugar or maple syrup instead of white sugar.
  • Herbal Touch: Fresh basil, oregano, or rosemary can enhance depth and aroma.
  • BBQ Flavor: Mix in a splash of smoky barbecue sauce.
  • Creamy Variant: A dollop of sour cream or cream cheese gives a creamier texture.
  • Garlic Boost: Increase garlic quantity for a stronger flavor.
  • Tomato-rich Version: Use tomato sauce instead of ketchup for a tangier taste.
  • Bean Addition: Some incorporate beans, merging chili and Coney characteristics.
  • Wine Infusion: Red wine can be reduced in the sauce for a luxurious twist.
Classic Coney Sauce

Recipe Directions 

Cooking Method

  • Place the ground onion and beef in a large skillet over medium-high heat. Cook, ensuring you stir often to crumble the beef until it’s thoroughly browned.
  • Once browned, drain the excess fat from the onion and beef mixture.
  • Transfer the drained onion and beef to a slow cooker.
  • Add ketchup, vinegar, sugar, and mustard to the slow cooker, ensuring even distribution.
  • Season the mixture with celery seed, pepper, Worcestershire sauce, and salt. Mix well.
  • Cover the slow cooker and set it to the ‘Low’ setting. Allow the mixture to simmer for 3-4 hours, ensuring the flavors meld together.
  • Once done, turn off the slow cooker and let the sauce rest for about 20 minutes before serving.

Ferment Method

Not applicable to this recipe.

Scaling The Recipe

  • Doubling: If you decide to make more, double each ingredient. However, ensure your slow cooker can accommodate the increased volume.
  • Halving: To make a smaller batch, halve each ingredient. Cooking time may reduce slightly, so monitor closely.
  • Spices: When scaling up, add spices cautiously. Doubling the recipe doesn’t always mean doubling the spice, as it can overwhelm.
  • Taste Test: Always taste as you adjust. This ensures the sauce remains balanced.
  • Consistency: If scaling up makes the sauce too thick, add some water or broth.
Classic Coney Sauce

Can This Sauce Be Used As A Marinade, Dipping Sauce, Or Dressing For Salads? 

  • Marinade: Its rich flavors can penetrate meats, making it suitable for marinating chicken or beef. Ensure your meat is marinated for a few hours or overnight for best results.
  • Dipping Sauce: By adjusting its consistency, possibly by thinning it with a bit of water or broth, it can serve as a dipping sauce for fries, chips, or bread.
  • Dressing for Salads: While unconventional, if you decide to experiment, you can use it as a base for salad dressing. Mix with olive oil and perhaps some vinegar to balance its richness.

What Are The Best Dishes To Accompany Classic Coney Sauce? 

  • Hot Dogs: The traditional choice; top a grilled hot dog with this sauce for a mouth-watering treat.
  • Burgers: Elevate your regular burgers by slathering them with this sauce.
  • Fries: Use as a hearty topping or side dip.
  • Nachos: Drizzle over tortilla chips, adding cheese and jalapeños.
  • Grilled Sandwiches: Add a layer inside for a flavor boost.
  • Pasta: As a meaty sauce alternative.
  • Baked Potatoes: A dollop on top with some cheese can be transformative.
  • Meatloaf: Use as a glaze or serve on the side.
  • Tacos: A non-traditional but flavorful filling.
  • Pizzas: As a base sauce or a topping for a unique twist.
Classic Coney Sauce

What Are Some Classic Dishes That Feature Classic Coney Sauce? 

  • Coney Island Hot Dog: A steamed hot dog with Coney Sauce, commonly garnished with mustard, onions, and cheese.
  • Coney Island Hamburger: Similar to the hot dog, but with a burger patty as the base.
  • Coney Fries: Crispy fries generously topped with Coney Sauce and sometimes sprinkled with cheese.
  • Coney Taco: A fusion dish that combines the sauce with taco shells and toppings.
  • Coney Chili Bowl: A hearty bowl filled with Coney Sauce, sometimes with beans or other additions.
  • Coney Pizza: Pizza crust layered with Coney Sauce, cheese, and typical hot dog toppings.

What Are The Key Flavor Profiles And Taste Sensations That Classic Coney Sauce Offers? 

  • Savory: The ground beef provides a deep, meaty richness.
  • Sweet: Ingredients like ketchup and sugar lend a mild sweetness.
  • Tangy: White vinegar and mustard introduce a zesty tanginess.
  • Spicy: Some heat may come from pepper or other spices, depending on the variation.
  • Earthy: Celery seed and Worcestershire sauce contribute a grounded, earthy note.
  • Umami: The combination of beef and Worcestershire sauce heightens the umami sensation.
  • Salty: Proper seasoning ensures a balanced saltiness, enhancing other flavors.
Classic Coney Sauce

Can This Sauce Be Stored And Preserved For Future Use? What Is Its Shelf Life? 

  • Refrigeration: In an airtight container, the sauce can last 4-5 days in the refrigerator. Ensure your container is sealed properly to maintain freshness.
  • Freezing: For longer storage, you can freeze the sauce. Divide it into portion-sized containers or freezer bags. It can last for up to 3 months. Thaw in the refrigerator before reheating.
  • Shelf Life: If kept at room temperature after cooking, it should be consumed within 2 hours. Beyond this, bacterial growth may occur, compromising safety.

What Are The Substitutes For Classic Coney Sauce? 

  • Chili Sauce: A thicker chili, without beans, can mimic the texture and richness of Coney Sauce.
  • BBQ Sauce: Offers a tangy, sweet profile, though less meaty.
  • Sloppy Joe Mix: While sweeter and tangier, it can quickly substitute.
  • Bolognese Sauce: An Italian meat sauce that gives a similar meaty texture.
  • Taco Meat: Seasoned ground beef used for tacos can be an alternative.
  • Bratwurst Sauce: It’s a savory sauce option typically used for sausages.
  • Tomato Sauce with Ground Meat: A simple combination that mimics the basic profile of Coney Sauce.
  • Mole Sauce: For a complex, deeper flavor with a hint of sweetness.
Classic Coney Sauce

How To Adjust The Consistency Of The Sauce? 

  • Thicker Sauce: If the sauce is too thin, continue simmering it uncovered. The prolonged cooking will evaporate excess moisture. Alternatively, you can add a cornstarch-water slurry (1-2 tsp of cornstarch mixed with equal water) to thicken it.
  • Thinner Sauce: If the sauce is too thick, add a bit of beef broth, water, or tomato sauce. Stir well and heat to ensure it blends seamlessly.
  • Creamier Texture: Add a dollop of sour cream or a splash of heavy cream to give it a creamy consistency.

Should We Serve The Sauce Cold Or Warm? 

Classic Coney Sauce is best served warm. When heated, the flavors meld together, enhancing the overall taste and ensuring the sauce spreads easily over dishes.

Serving it warm complements its traditional accompaniments like hot dogs, hamburgers, and fries, bringing a cozy, comforting feel.

However, if you decide to use it as a dip or in a salad dressing, it may be served at room temperature or slightly chilled.

But heating it up is typically the key to experiencing the sauce in its full glory. If stored in the refrigerator, always reheat before serving to bring out its best flavor and texture.

Classic Coney Sauce

Nutritional Values 

Classic Coney Sauce is a good source of protein. However, our recipe indicates minimal protein content, with its primary ingredient being ground beef.

It also contains sugars, primarily from ketchup, making it a source of carbohydrates. The sauce has sodium, derived from added salt and other ingredients like Worcestershire sauce.

While it provides some vitamins, such as Vitamin A and C, it’s advisable to enjoy this sauce as part of a balanced diet, considering its caloric and sodium content. Let’s dive in deep to find out more nutritional value.

What Are The Total Calories In Classic Coney Sauce? 

The total calories in Classic Coney Sauce depend on the exact ingredients and their quantities. Each ingredient’s nutritional value must be considered to ascertain precise calorie counts. 

The main calorie sources are ground beef, ketchup, and sugar. On average, a serving might range from 25 to 30 calories, but this is a ballpark figure. For precise caloric information, it’s advisable to consult a nutrition calculator or software using the specific recipe’s details.

Dietary Restrictions Of The Classic Coney Sauce 

  • Gluten: Ingredients like Worcestershire sauce may contain gluten. Check labels or find gluten-free versions.
  • Meat: The sauce is not vegetarian or vegan due to ground beef.
  • Sugar: Not suitable for low-sugar or sugar-free diets.
  • Preservatives: Ketchup may contain preservatives or high fructose corn syrup.
  • Salt: Might be high in sodium, not ideal for low-sodium diets.
  • Allergens: Mustard can be an allergen for some.
  • Vinegar: Those with acid reflux or certain digestive conditions may need to avoid or reduce vinegar.

Nutrition Table

Nutrition Table

What Are The Common Mistakes While Making This Sauce?

  • Overcooking the Beef: This can result in a dry, crumbly texture. It’s key to cook the beef just until browned.
  • Not Draining the Beef: Failing to drain the beef can make the sauce too greasy.
  • Rushing the Simmering Process: Not allowing the sauce to simmer long enough can prevent flavors from melding.
  • Overseasoning: Adding too much salt or spices can overpower the sauce. Always season in increments.
  • Using Low-Quality Ingredients: This may affect the taste and consistency. For instance, a watery ketchup can make the sauce thin.
  • Skipping Ingredients: Leaving out elements like celery seed or Worcestershire sauce can change the sauce’s authentic taste.
  • Not Tasting As You Go: This may result in an imbalanced flavor profile. Always taste and adjust seasonings as necessary.
  • Not Stirring Occasionally: During simmering, neglecting to stir can result in the sauce sticking to the bottom or burning.
  • Improper Storage: If not stored properly, the sauce can spoil quickly.

What Are Some Creative Uses Of Leftover Sauce? 

  • Pasta Mix-In: Blend it with pasta for a meaty twist.
  • Nachos Topping: Drizzle over nachos, add cheese, and bake.
  • Stuffed Bell Peppers: Fill peppers with sauce and rice, then bake.
  • Omelet Filling: Elevate your breakfast with a sauce-infused omelet.
  • Pizza Base: Use as a savory spread on pizza crust before adding toppings.
  • Sandwich Spread: Layer it in sandwiches or burgers for added flavor.
  • Baked Potatoes: Top baked or mashed potatoes for a hearty side.
  • Quesadilla Filling: Combine with cheese in a tortilla, then grill.
  • Casserole Layer: Incorporate into casseroles for depth and richness.
Classic Coney Sauce

Special Tools & Equipment Needed 

  • Large Skillet: Essential for browning the ground beef and onions evenly.
  • Slow Cooker: Allows for slow simmering, letting flavors meld perfectly.
  • Wooden Spoon: Great for stirring without scratching your cookware.
  • Chopping Board: Necessary for chopping onions and other ingredients if added.
  • Sharp Knife: For finely chopping onions and ensuring clean cuts.
  • Measuring Cups & Spoons: For accurate ingredient measurements.
  • Airtight Containers: Useful for storage, ensuring freshness.
  • Fine Mesh Strainer: Helps in draining excess grease from the browned meat.
  • Mixing Bowls: Useful if blending or mixing additional ingredients.
  • Heat-Resistant Gloves: Provide safety when handling hot cookware.

Frequently Asked Questions  

What Is Classic Coney Sauce Traditionally Used For?

Classic Coney Sauce is traditionally used as a topping for hot dogs, giving them a rich, savory flavor. However, its versatility means it can be paired with various other dishes.

Can I Make This Sauce Vegetarian Or Vegan?

Yes, you can substitute ground beef with plant-based alternatives, such as lentils, textured vegetable protein (TVP), or vegan ground meat substitutes. Ensure your ketchup and Worcestershire sauce are also vegan or vegetarian-friendly.

How Long Can I Store Leftover Sauce?

Once cooled to room temperature, refrigerate the sauce in an airtight container. It typically lasts up to a week. For longer storage, consider freezing.

Is There A Way To Make This Sauce Spicier Or Milder?

To add heat, you can introduce some chili powder, cayenne pepper, or hot sauce to taste. For a milder version, reduce or eliminate spicy ingredients and add more sugar to balance flavors.

Can I Cook The Sauce Without A Slow Cooker?

Yes, if you decide to use a stovetop method, simply simmer the mixture in a pot over low heat, ensuring you stir regularly to prevent sticking or burning. Adjust the cooking time accordingly, keeping an eye on consistency and flavor development.

Classic Coney Sauce Recipe – Thick And Rich Flavor

0 from 0 votes
Recipe by Lana Rivera Course: Hot Sauces
Servings

8

servings
Prep time

15

minutes
Cooking time

3

hours 
Calories

45

kcal
Ferment/Rest Time

20

minutes

Classic Coney Sauce is a rich, savory meat sauce with a harmonious blend of tangy, sweet, and mildly spiced flavors. Traditionally drizzled over hot dogs, this sauce elevates the ordinary to extraordinary.

Ingredients

  • 2 pounds 2 Ground beef

  • 1/2 cup 1/2 Chopped onion

  • 1 1/2 cups 1 1/2 Ketchup

  • 1/4 cup 1/4 White sugar

  • 1/4 cup 1/4 White vinegar

  • 1/4 cup 1/4 Prepared yellow mustard

  • 1/2 teaspoon 1/2 Celery seed

  • 3/4 teaspoon 3/4 Worcestershire sauce

  • 1/2 teaspoon 1/2 Ground black pepper

  • 3/4 teaspoon 3/4 Salt

Step-By-Step Directions

  • Prepare Ingredients
    Finely chop the onion.
    Measure out all other ingredients and set them aside.
  • Brown the Beef
    Place the ground beef and chopped onion in a large skillet.
    Cook over medium-high heat, stirring continuously to crumble the beef until it is fully browned.
  • Drain the Beef
    Once the beef is browned, drain the excess fat using a fine mesh strainer.
  • Transfer to Slow Cooker
    Move the drained onion and beef mix into the slow cooker.
  • Add Remaining Ingredients
    Stir in the slow cooker with the ketchup, sugar, vinegar, and mustard.
    Season the mixture with celery seed, Worcestershire sauce, black pepper, and salt.
  • Simmer the Sauce
    Cover the slow cooker and set it on a Low setting.
    Allow the sauce to simmer for a few hours. This slow cooking melts the flavors together and enhances the sauce’s depth.
  • Stir Occasionally
    To ensure even cooking and to prevent sticking, remember to stir the sauce from time to time.
  • Serve Warm
    Once cooked, serve the sauce warm over your dish of choice.
  • Storage
    If you have leftovers, allow the sauce to cool to room temperature.
    Transfer to an airtight container and refrigerate for future use.

Notes

  • The sauce’s consistency can be adjusted to one’s preference by extending the simmering time for a thicker consistency or by adding liquid for a thinner one.
  • Always taste and adjust seasonings as needed. Fresh ingredients yield the best results.
  • Leftovers can be creatively repurposed in various dishes, ensuring no wastage.
Lana Rivera
Share

Leave a Comment